9th September 2010

Angry, Upset & Disappointing

posted in Belle, Educational |

I am terribly upset today.

I am so upset that I can’t help but to cry when I called Jon to tell him that a teacher or even teachers think our child is uncontrollable. It is like a big stamp on my forehead saying I fail as a parent. This is how upset I am.

I am not upset with my child but I am so sick of hearing teachers kept telling me, “Isabelle doesn’t listen well.” “Isabelle can’t sit still.” “Isabelle isn’t writing nicely.” “You will have to revise with her on the Chinese characters just so she doesn’t feel left out or has less confidence” “I want to get on with the teaching schedule but by not knowing these simple set of characters I can’t move on.” And then they would contradict by saying, “Oh, she is still young (she is a Nov baby), give her time.” “Oh, we don’t want to push her too hard till she doesn’t like Chinese school.”

It is all BULL SHIT!

At the very beginning, before enrolling her into the Chinese after-school program, I told the teachers my child is not a Mandarin speaker at home. We were also given the impression that we will not need to do ANY revision with her during weekends because they will have ample exposure to Mandarin from Monday to Friday. They had also told us they will separate the English speakers from the Mandarin speakers just so they won’t feel “stupid” for not knowing Mandarin in the first place.

What I’m seeing now is, ALL the Kinder kids are in the same class. It is understandable that some of these kids will excel in Mandarin ‘cos they speak it at home. Majority were brought up by Mandarin speaker grandparents, hence giving them an edge in Mandarin.

I am so angry and upset beyond words. Since school started I have put in so much emphasis on getting my child up to speed with what they expect her to know. I made flash cards of the Chinese characters. Everyday I made sure we had at least 30 to 45 minutes of revision time going over those characters AND on top of that, getting her familiarize with addition.

What I’m feeling now is disappointment. It made me feel as though all those effort and energy spent were not enough for them to appreciate how far along my child has came, especially when she is only into the third week of Chinese school AND not a Mandarin speaker.

Yes, I am upset, angry and disappointed. The reason we put her in this “rigid” environment is to prepare her for the real Chinese kindergarten environment in Malaysia. We want her to get use to a Chinese environment and we thought easing her into it, especially in a US-based Chinese school, would be easier for her. Apparently not. They expect ALL kids to be typical Chinese kids where obedience is #1. What they forgot was my child is not a Mandarin speaker. Majority of the time they would speak to the children in Mandarin and give instruction in Chinese. I know it is to get the kids use to listening to Mandarin but for a non-Mandarin speaker/listener, it means shit. Of course my kid is not going to listen or obey them ‘cos she doesn’t even know what they want from her!

Pure disappointment! I’m so upset I told Jon I can’t speak to the teachers today, he will have to do it. So we will see how it goes. My tummy is growling but I have no appetite to eat anymore.

This entry was posted on Thursday, September 9th, 2010 at 10:20 pm and is filed under Belle, Educational. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

There are currently 22 cheeky cheeks to “Angry, Upset & Disappointing”

Do you have the cheeks to comment?

  1. 1 On September 10th, 2010, Irene said:

    Ouch!
    That sucks. Give ‘em hell!

  2. 2 On September 10th, 2010, yvy said:

    crikey…. :( poor u….poor isabelle!!! that really does suck, when she went to school in US, was she learning mandarin as well, or just started here? u already plan to send her to mandarin school? i really hope it works out for u ler. (hugs)

  3. 3 On September 10th, 2010, ???? said:

    ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
    ????????????????????????????????????????
    ????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
    ?????????????????? ???????????????????program?input?then run??????????????????????????????????
    ???????????????????????????
    ????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

  4. 4 On September 10th, 2010, felicity said:

    reality bites. so change schools, or change your expectations; whether of the school or of your child. Above all, do not get angry, upset, or disappointed. Believe me, none of these emotions will solve the ‘problem’, if at all it is really a problem. Just be concerned and be matter-of-fact, that will be the best thing you can do for your daughter.

  5. 5 On September 10th, 2010, mom2ashleyaidan said:

    Oh dear…I hope it gets better.
    I can feel your disappointment.

  6. 6 On September 10th, 2010, Gigi said:

    Relaaaaaaax, i grew up hearing those things. Once my mom came to pick me up at school, my English teacher said something bad, my mom was so upset, she turned around and left w/o saying anthing. Even my English teacher was surprised, she aske me, “so your mom just left ?” I was so embarrassed, I was 10 or 11 back then. Don’t be upset in front of them, they’re just kid. See my bro and I turned out fine lol

  7. 7 On September 10th, 2010, michelle said:

    I experienced almost the same thing with Tim with his very first school, cannot read, cannot spell, cannot add…etc. After I changed his school with a teacher who is very patient with him, made him learn and he excel. Yeah I did the flash card too. By the way, it is English, not even Mandarin.

    It is the teacher. If it does not work out for her, find a school with teachers who understand. She is still young, takes time to pick up a new language. After that it will be smooth sailing.

    Don’t feel disappointed but never give up trying. :)

  8. 8 On September 11th, 2010, justina said:

    “doesn’t listen well., can’t sit still – these 2 probs you gotta solve yourself. The other ones i.e. isn’t writing nicely, etc.’, take it as an assessment of your kid’s literacy skills. You’ve tried your best to help, but it looks like Belle is just not ready for this class of peers.

    If it were me, I would send her to some other place where kids are of the same ‘level’. This will be better for her learning progress and more important, better for her self-confidence.

    Actually, if there was a problem like this with my kid, I would want to be the first to know about it so I can fix it quick. I wouldn’t want them to pretend everything is hunky dory.

  9. 9 On September 11th, 2010, khongfamily said:

    Vien, I’m sure I will be feeling lousy too if I were you. Does Belle like the school or complain about the teachers/school? If yes, you may have to consider transferring her to another school. Does Belle like Mandarin medium school? Can’t force her if she doesn’t seem to like it. Oh ya, must she be in Chinese kindergarten when she is in Malaysia? Hope everything will work out well for you guys!

  10. 10 On September 11th, 2010, mama bok said:

    Hey Vien,
    Sorry to hear about this – I know how you feel – it was the same with Chloe and her french teacher remember? Chloe was put in special class for everything even writing *slap forehead* – it sure made me feel like a bad mother. But it’s the teacher – not chloe – you see she excelled with Ms Tish – she excelled with Mrs Hubbard and she excelled even more with Mrs Bowers. Now she has a good teacher too – Mrs O’ Brien. So don’t you worry (i know it is hard not to) but trust me – Belle will do well – everything will fall into its place. *huggggggggs* – sometimes – teachers like that need to go back to training again – they are just not fit to be teachers.

  11. 11 On September 12th, 2010, aida said:

    vien, sorry to hear this, soo irritating eh!

  12. 12 On September 14th, 2010, zmm said:

    Oh wow, I thought in US the teachers will be more professional.. looks like it’s not the case.

    My girls’ Chinese sucks too. But they don’t get such comments from school, except I was told to speak to her more in Chinese, and expose her more to Chinese.

  13. 13 On September 14th, 2010, Shooi said:

    Hi dear..hope u feel better now. I don’t think you should worry about Belle being able to adapt to a chinese kindy. It is amazing how fast the kids will learn eventually. In Bryan’s school there is a Japanese kid whose mother just decided to enrol him in Std 1 chinese school next year. So the teachers are working real hard to prep him since they don’t speak mandarin at home. And he seems to be coping fine…

    I do not speak any English/ Malay when i first started Std 1, and I hated school then because I do not know what is going on. But at Std 3, I started to enter elocution, story telling and poetry recital competitions and actually won some of them. It took me a while but eventually i got used to the language.

    So don’t worry about Belle not having an early start and forget about those competitive inconsiderate afterschool teachers. You are doing fine with Belle! *hugs**

  14. 14 On September 14th, 2010, Immomsdaughter said:

    Hey Vien, sorry to hear about the teacher’s feedback. However, I don’t think it’s Belle’s progress that’s the problem. Like most of the mommies here noticed, I think the way with which the teacher is handling the matter is like she’s not properly trainedlah. Trust me, when I first sent Ryan to a Mandarin kindy, he did not know a single mandarin word. It took him at least a month to pick up some words and three weeks is too early to expect so much from such a young child who has no knowledge of mandarin.

    Mei Mei is in her final (3rd) year of kindy and they only started teaching Mandarin in her 2nd year. And that’s only one book in Mandarin, the rest are taught in English. Even at this rate, they are expected to have no problem when they progress to Chinese Primary School. So, don’t worry too much. My advice is if you have a choice (and do not believe in the system the school practice), try to change school. Just my 2 cents ya.

  15. 15 On September 14th, 2010, UC said:

    i hope things will get better, dear.

    *hugs*

  16. 16 On September 14th, 2010, Mamapumpkin said:

    Just so you know, it is always the teachers fault. If the teacher cannot get a kid to do something, then they aren’t a good enough teacher. Period.

    I wouldn’t stress out about it. Are you coming back for good? When? Are you absolutely sure you’re sending her to a Chinese school here? Find out what the syllabus is here and take it from there. Under the right environment and approach, she will be fine. All kids are, unless they have some learning disability, in which case, it can be addressed and they will be fine too.

  17. 17 On September 15th, 2010, chanelwong said:

    Poor Belle…
    You will sure be able to find the solution….

  18. 18 On September 17th, 2010, syn said:

    and i would think the teachers there are better than the ones here! vien, pull her out! belle can learn mandarin here…looks like the chinese teachers there are so backwards! anyway, rye li is also learning in school and she is hopeless with it at home but at least she tries with her papa. so really, please don’t feel disappointed, it’s not belle, it’s the teachers. u know kids pick up language easily so let belle learn it the malaysian way! ;)

    see you all year end!

  19. 19 On September 17th, 2010, Etceteramommy said:

    Strange the teachers have so high expectation on the children. Even so, few weeks is simply too early to label and cast Belle so negatively. Really teruk. I hope the teachers would at least be more tactile and professional with their premature feedback in front of the kids. Good luck.

  20. 20 On September 22nd, 2010, mommy to chumsy said:

    sorry to hear this, vien. ashley’s teachers tell me the same thing too but they are not too concerned about her not being to sit still so i just keep one eye closed. some kids are like so i guess our daughters are different? ashley also does not know how to speak mandarin despite being in a chinese-based kindy since Jan. maybe later on she will catch up so right now i am not worried about that. what actually do belle’s teachers expect you to do? stop her from attending class? i hope all is well now. take care. i was chatting with your aunt at your cousin’s bakery and she told me you’ll be back very soon :)

  21. 21 On September 24th, 2010, KittyCat said:

    I hear you, my dear, especially as I have been getting calls and notes and talks from the preschool back home about how FIDGETY and HYPER-ACTIVE the boy is.

    Teachers can be a pain esp if they’re in the public school system – you can’t really blame them since 90% of parents are kiasu —> pressure on the principals —> pressure on the teachers —> pressure on the kids!

    Give it a bit of time, ok? And do keep up with the revision at home – it really helps! You could either change schools or talk to the principal on how BOTH parties could work to help Belle.

    Are you that set on going to a Chinese primary school? I was 100% moving on to 50-50 because our boy is too talkative, hyperactive and too anti-establishment. Chinese school may either break his spirit or make him rebellious and we definitely don’t want that!

  22. 22 On January 13th, 2011, Yvonne Lai said:

    hey vien, where have you been? haven’t seen any updates and you have been too quiet lately. hope things are going well. I just read this blog post and found it really interesting in trying to raise a bilingual kid. Hmm, we’re school searching for my Isaac. 2 more years to go to kindergarten and yeah, we’re already looking but gosh, we think it’s better to start early than rushing toward the end to meet the application deadlines or what not. anyways, let’s chat if you have a chance.

Leave a Reply

  • Calendar

  • May 2013
    M T W T F S S
    « Dec    
     12345
    6789101112
    13141516171819
    20212223242526
    2728293031  
  • Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket
  • Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape
  • Help Paying Bills

  • Parent Reviewers
  • Get Paid Money to Blog

Spread the Word
delicious
digg
technorati
reddit
magnolia
stumbleupon
yahoo
google